How To Trick Your Brothers Girlfriend

Cole develops an unhealthy obsession with his brother’s girlfriend Sophie but how far will he take it?

Sophie (19) had been with her boyfriend James (22) for 4 years. The couple had their expected trials and tribulations after meeting at a young age. They had grown a lot together since they had first met, even though at 23 James wasn’t considered mature for his age. Sophie had light blonde hair, tanned skin and green eyes. She had filled out a lot over the 5 years of knowing each other, Sophie had grown into wearing sized E bra and an ass that had filled out nicely too. She had also had these incredible thick legs. Sophie didn’t always feel appreciated enough from her boyfriend James but she loved him nonetheless. There was someone who did appreciate Sophie… James’s creepy older brother Cole.

Cole (27) was secretly obsessed with Sophie even if he had a girlfriend of his own. His girlfriend Lucy (23) was a short girl who had been with Cole for 4 years. She loved Cole a lot, even if she didn’t feel the same affection back and knowing deep down that Cole was attracted to Sophie. It wasn’t until the past year or so that Cole started to feel this way towards Sophie. It began when the two couples went on holiday and Cole saw Sophie in a bikini for the first time. From that moment on his obsession has grown to be unhealthy. Both of the brothers still lived at home with their parents, meaning Sophie and Lucy were round a lot. Lucy was jealous of Sophie, the way she looked and dressed more so of the creepy comments he would make about his brother’s girlfriend.

One time when James was in a different room, Cole went up to Sophie and hugged her from behind while really pressing his cock up against her ass. He has made comments about the way she looks numerous times and also subtly hinted at how he would love to fuck her, making this hint in front of his brother and family. Sophie would complain to James about how creepy he is, she found him to be disgusting. She wanted James to say something to his brother, James however feared his brother deep down. Cole was a big guy, he had brown hair and a beard, he was tall like his brother and loved to go to the gym. Cole’s secret obsession with his brother’s girlfriend ran much deeper than anyone could have known.

Sophie would stay round the family house quite a lot. When Sophie and James left the house, Cole would sneak into their room and sniff Sophie’s dirty panties without his girlfriend knowing. He was desperate to see her nakedness to the point he was searching through his brother’s phone to find pictures. He didn’t have any luck finding them but managed to get a few ass pictures that his brother had taken. He often masturbated over the photos using Sophie’s underwear, he did it so much that he barely had sex with his own girlfriend. The fantasies he had created in his own head had gotten to the point where he needed to do something about it…

———————————————

It was a random week in the early summer, Lucy had left the country to go on holiday with some of her friends. That same week James and Cole’s parents had gone on holiday abroad too. This had left James and Cole to look after the house for the week. The brothers were working all week but Cole had been plotting something while alone each night in his room. It was Saturday and James had a soccer game in the afternoon. After every soccer game the team went out for drinks and food, sometimes staying out late but James typically avoided it. The team bus had picked James up for the game, it was a long 2.5 hour journey to the location of the game. It wasn’t until the bus had gone and left that James had realised that he didn’t have his phone. There was no time for the bus to turn around. Little did he know that his brother Cole had stolen his phone just as he was leaving.

Sophie had stayed round the night before and was working during the day on Saturday. While working, Sophie had received a text from what she thought was James.

“I miss you so much baby. Can’t wait to be with you tonight, I can’t lie I want to try something with you x.”

Sophie felt quite pleased by the message, she was having a difficult day at work but was curious by what ‘James’ meant by wanting to try something.

“I miss you too. What is it that you wanted to try baby? x.”

Sophie replied to the text feeling intrigued by what he could possibly mean. Her heart dropped at the reply.

“I wanted to try something quite kinky with you, I’ve laid a special little present for you on the bed that I wanted you to wear for when I get back from the game. Cole is out tonight so we have the house to ourselves! x.”

Sophie’s heart fluttered. ‘James’ had never been like this with her but she was totally into it. The sex was good but it was just normal sex, nothing overly kinky about it. The prospect of having the house to themselves was music to Sophie’s ears, especially the thought of Cole not being there.

“Sounds good to me ;)! x”

Sophie texted back. This gave her the extra buzz to get through the day, she couldn’t wait to get back to ‘James’s’ house.

Cole had this planned out perfectly, he awaited patiently for Sophie’s arrival home from work. This wasn’t all that Cole planned, he had managed to convince James’s teammates to make James stay out drinking after the game so he had plenty of time. The prospect of James arriving back this Saturday evening was next to none…

Sophie had arrived back from work at around 6:30pm that evening, she knew that she had around an hour left before ‘James arrived home’. James was currently out for a post game dinner with his teammates, having no idea of what was going on at home. Sophie went upstairs and before going into James’s room, she looked in Cole’s room to see if Cole was actually out. He wasn’t in his room but he was actually in the garage waiting. After getting the all clear, Sophie headed to the bedroom to see what was lying on the bed. It was a baby pink laced bra with a matching thong with white laced hold ups. Alongside the lingerie was a blindfold, Sophie’s innocence caused some nerves to kick in.

Cole waited patiently in the garage, he had set a small spy camera in the bedroom to keep an eye on the right moment. Sophie had jumped in the shower, she was making sure he was clean and completely shaved. After her shower she put on some makeup including red lipstick, she put her hair up in a slick back pony tail with two bits of hair hanging either side of her temple. She slipped on the lingerie, it looked unbelievable on her. The laced bra showed on her round pink nipples and the thong just about covered her asshole. After this it was just about coming up to 7:30, Sophie stepped out of the bathroom and sat on the bed awaiting the arrival of ‘James’. Cole watched her walk in and was as hard as anything watching her juicy ass in the baby pink thong from the pixelated camera, it was time…

Cole walked in through the front door, Sophie heard the sound of it opening and quickly put the blindfold on as requested. Cole was only in his boxer shorts, his cock was rock hard ad he made his way up the stairs. He had a camera attached to his head recording as POV. He couldn’t believe the plan had worked as he slowly opened the door to his brother’s bedroom. Cole walked in and saw Sophie sitting there pretty awkwardly on the bed. Her tits looked unbelievable sitting there in the lingerie he had organised for her. Cole didn’t waste any time and immediately pulled his boxers down and his 7inch thick cock sprung out. He approached Sophie and grabbed her hand, getting her to stand up. Sophie was nervous waiting for what she thought was her boyfriend, was going to do next.

Cole had shaved his beard to a similar length to his brothers to avoid suspicion. He began kissing her body, beginning with her neck while reaching down and grabbing a handful of her right ass cheek. Sophie had began to feel the sensation of her thong becoming wet, as well as the feeling of Cole’s cock pressed up against her thick left leg. He was caressing and kissing her body all over, licking Sophie’s skin. Cole ran his finger over the thong strap that covered her pucker. Sophie was always hesitant about James touching her asshole so whispered ‘no’ as he did it. That wasn’t going to stop Cole anytime soon as he had fantasised about fucking Sophie’s tight asshole. As he was caressing and kissing her body, he knelt down and bit onto her ass cheek.

Cole then placed Sophie’s hand onto his cock who began to jerk in motion slowly. Sophie suddenly thought it felt thicker than usual but thought she may of been going crazy. Cole grabbed and squeezed her magnificent breasts, making Sophie moan. He then reached out and grabbed a pair of handcuffs that he had secretly stored on a shelf. Moving behind her while kissing her, he grabbed her wrists and cuffed her hands together behind her back. Cole sniffed Sophie’s blonde hair and pushed her down to her knees. He moved himself back in front of his brother’s blindfolded girlfriend and his cock was pointing directly at her face. To Sophie’s surprise, Cole grabbed her chin making her look up and he slapped his cock onto her face. The camera was capturing it perfectly as he did this.

Cole then pushed his cock into Sophie’s mouth, it was a feeling he had been waiting a long time for. Sophie gagged as he thrusted himself back and forth slowly. Cole felt her uvula as he watched drool fall out of her mouth, falling onto her breasts. Sophie had perched her lips together as tightly as possible around it, hoping to please her ‘boyfriend’. Cole pulled out her mouth lifted his cock up, pushing his balls towards her mouth as she gracefully began sucking onto them. Cole’s head tilted back for a moment in pleasure but he ensured to look down again so the camera could see Sophie sucking his balls. She had no idea that it wasn’t James’s balls she was sucking.

After a few more minutes of thrusting his cock into her mouth and watching drool fall all over her breasts Cole decided to lift her up onto her feet. He came from behind her and removed the handcuffs temporarily to make her lay down onto her back on the bed. Gravity had made Sophie’s tits lay down with her. The bed was a steel framed bed with metal poles. Cole lifted her hands up over her head and cuffed them to the frame ensuring she was secure. Sophie had been shifted round by Cole so he has her in the position to kneel over bed with his face directing her pussy. Sophie had only received oral sex from James once and it wasn’t overly pleasurable so she wasn’t looking forward to this.

Cole pushed Sophie’s knees up towards her ass and pulled her in closer to him. He slowly moved her thong to the side, revealing her hairless pussy. Leaning himself forward, Cole began using his tongue in a swirling motion to lick Sophie’s clitoris.

“Oh my fucking god,” Sophie moaned out.

Her thick legs uncontrollably squeezed themselves together tightly on Cole’s head. It tasted better than Cole could have imagined, he had been waiting for this moment for a long time. Sophie suddenly became extremely wet as Cole moved down towards her inner labia making her shuffle around. Cole leant himself back and pushed his middle finger towards Sophie’s vaginal opening and slid it gently in. Sophie was moaning, feeling the pleasure from her boyfriend’s brother unknowingly. After sliding his finger the full way in, he pulled it out and sucked on the juices from her pussy. Cole buried his face back towards her and began putting his tongue inside her vagina as far as he could.

Cole was loving every moment of this, he pulled his face away for a moment and pushed Sophie knees up into the air making her ass follow. He made sure the strap was moved to the side so he could see her tight pink pucker. Not being able to help himself Cole pushed his tongue towards her asshole making Sophie screech.

“No baby, not there,” Sophie moaned out.

It didn’t stop Cole however, he was thoroughly enjoying the taste of her virgin pucker. Sophie gave in, the feeling was unlike anything she had felt before. Cole licked up and down like her asshole was a lollipop, Sophie unable to stop him. Following this, Cole lifted his head back up and began kissing down her leg while slowly pulling down the white hold ups. All the way down to her feet, where he began molesting them with his tongue pulling both off of her. She had these small, perfectly soft feet that Cole couldn’t get enough of. However, he was now ready to fuck his brother’s girlfriend.

Cole lifted himself up onto his feet and pulled Sophie closer to him, ensuring her thong strap was still to the side. Her hands still being cuffed to the frame of the bed. Cole grabbed onto his rock solid cock and pressed it against Sophie’s soaking wet pussy. He slowly began pushing it in, Cole’s heart was now fluttering as he had been fantasising about this moment. Sophie’s vagina felt tight as Cole entered inside of her, he was amazed at how good it felt. Sophie was moaning out, which was turning Cole on even more. He began thrusting himself back and forth slowly.

“Uhh fuck me,” Sophie moaned out loudly.

Cole began thrusting harder and faster, each thrust making her breasts bounce. Sophie couldn’t believe how good it was feeling, she enjoyed being cuffed to the bed. Cole grabbed her legs up into the air, held them together and continued to roughly fuck his brother’s girlfriend. He was letting out grunts that surprisingly didn’t budge Sophie in the slightest. The camera was catching the beauty of her tits bouncing, it was like he was filming a porno.

After enjoying the pleasures of Sophie in the missionary position, Cole was eager to see the 19 year old on her front. He pulled out and moved himself to unlock the cuffs from the bed. Sophie was flipped over on to her front there and re cuffed to the bed immediately. Sophie’s nicely shaped juicy ass was now on better show for Cole. He moved himself behind her and began slowly pulling down her thong to see her bare ass. Without hesitation Cole buried his face into her ass, almost performing the motorboat. He licked her asshole once again making Sophie moan while feeling conflicted about it. Only this time Cole pushed his tongue into her pucker making her scream. She shuffled around feeling uncomfortable but he was loving every moment of it.

Once Cole had, had his fun with her asshole. He lifted himself back up, as well as lifting Sophie’s ass up so it was in the air. Cole pushed his cock back into Sophie’s pussy and slapped her ass cause a small ripple effect. Sophie thought to herself for a moment as to where ‘James’ had all this sudden sex drive from. Nevertheless, she didn’t have much time to think about it as Cole’s cock was slamming into her vagina. Each thrust now making Sophie’s ass jiggle, it was perfect for the camera. While pounding her from behind, Cole decided to test her resolve once again. He slid his thumb over her pink pucker and began pressing down onto it.

“Baby, uhh fuck,” Sophie moaned out, not being able to say much as he was pressing himself deeply into her.

Cole decided to pull out for a moment and moved himself away to grab something. He had also planted a small pot of baby oil in James’s bed side table draw. He re entered his cock into Sophie and began squirting cold baby oil all over her ass. He started to spread it all over, making it look like a thing of beauty. Sophie’s ass was shiny and oily as he thrusted himself hard inside of her, thrusting hard and stopping for a moment and so on. Sophie couldn’t believe what was going on, this was so unlike ‘James’. She began to wonder while taking Cole’s cock if ‘James’ had been watching porn behind her back to get these ideas.

Cole wanted to try something else, he pulled himself out feeling like he could have came while having her in doggy position. He removed the cuffs from the bed frame once again. He freed her hands separately for a moment and removed her bra finally. Her teen tits were unbelievable, the best he has ever seen. After removing the bra, he cuffed her hands back together, Cole then pushed her back onto the bed so she was lying down. Sophie was anticipating what might be coming next. Cole began rubbing the baby oil all over her tits, so just like her ass they were all oily and shiny. He knelt down and shoved his cock back inside of her, slowly thrusting himself back and forth.

Cole then lifted Sophie up while inside of her, making her cuffed hands go over his head. He began thrusting himself back and forth inside of her while holding her up when Sophie noticed something wasn’t right. She knew that her boyfriend was not this muscular and Cole knew that she would now know it was James. He reached up and pulled off her blindfold while continuing to fuck her…

“No no no, what the fuck.” Sophie moaned out as she quickly realised it was Cole and not James. Cole was still inside of her and had reached the point of wanting to cum. He began cumming inside of her, impregnating her. Sophie couldn’t believe what was happening, she had been tricked by someone she strongly disliked. Cum was filling up inside of Sophie, as he continued to hold her up. Sophie had been enjoying what she thought was the best sex she had ever had with her ‘boyfriend’ only to find out while doing it that it was his brother.

Cole finally put Sophie down back onto the bed. She was stunned and a bit tearful from what had happened. It took Sophie a moment to realise that there was a camera on his head that had filmed everything. Cole didn’t stop just there however, he grabbed onto the cuffs that was on Sophie’s wrists and made her come with him to the bathroom. He made Sophie climb into the bath and aimed his cock directly at her before a stream of piss began shooting all over her. Sophie closed her eyes and tried to close her mouth, she was stunned. Cole was laughing as he drenched Sophie in urine. After he had finished, he turned on the shower and helped clean her up.

Sophie didn’t know what to say, the worst part for her is that she was enjoying it. After the shower, Cole whispered something in Sophie’s ear.

“You belong to me now baby…”

Sophie made her way back to James’s bedroom, contemplating everything. She tidied up his room as best as she could and ended up making her way home. She had realised that Cole had deleted all messages between on the message chat meaning James couldn’t see what had truly happened. Sophie couldn’t bring herself to tell James the truth when she eventually saw him the next day. Cole had messaged Sophie the next day:

“Drinks next Saturday 8pm then the hotel in town. Don’t be late 😉 x.”

Sophie had to make a decision. She had to tell James the truth and break his heart or secretly give herself to Cole behind his back…

Part 2 this week!!!